MyCarTSB

2019 Bmw X5 Engine Problems

31 owner-reported engine complaints from NHTSA data

31
Complaints
Jan 2026Dec 2024
Date Range

Data sourced from NHTSA public database. For informational purposes only. Always consult a qualified mechanic.

Owner Complaints (31)

criticalENGINE
Filed: Feb 2026

Subject: 2019 BMW X5 xDrive40i – Oil Pump Defect Causing Oil Measurement Failure and Safety Risk I am reporting a safety defect in my 2019 BMW X5 xDrive40i with the 3.0L B58 inline-6 engine. The vehicle currently has approximately 70,000 miles.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11718348
criticalENGINE
Filed: Feb 2026

BMW knowingly did NOT NOTIFY it's 2019 BMW X5 M40i (engine B58) vehicle owners. This is in reference to the faulty design and made plastic engine oil pump. It has been known to fail prematurely due to weaken parts.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11715013
criticalENGINE
Filed: Jan 2026

Premature oil pump failure. 2019 BMW x5 with only 46k miles has been diagnosed with an oil pump failure. Vehicle needed to be quickly pulled over and shut off to avoid catastrophic engine failure or engine seize.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11714340
criticalENGINE
Filed: Oct 2025

The oil pump contains a plastic housing that fractured during regular use. (Yes, I did retain the part for inspection and can include photos of the defect here). Yes, the problem has been confirmed by my mechanic and the general public with multiple posts and videos shared widely across the internet and in vehicle forums.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11690949
criticalENGINE
Filed: Mar 2025

The starter motor overheats when the vehicle tries to start. The car does not always start. You can smell the starter burning.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11650949
criticalENGINE
Filed: Jan 2025

I received an Important Safety Recall notice indicating that a manufacturing defect could cause my vehicle to catch fire. I brought the car to New Country BMW in Hartford, CT to have this corrected and was advised that I would be charged $2,200 to replace the "TCB" in order to address the safety recall. This does not seem right to charge me to correct a safety defect mandated by NHTSA.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11639674
criticalENGINE,FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM
Filed: Sep 2019

Driving on I-95, dashboard displayed: "vehicle on fire." immediate call to bmw. No such icon or possible entry in bmw vehicles (2 dealerships). Drive to dealership and diagnostics run with no issue with system.

NHTSA #: 11258802
highENGINE
Filed: Mar 2026

I am writing to report a significant safety issue associated with BMW vehicles equipped with the B58TU engine, particularly the 2019-2021 models. These vehicles feature an oil pump containing an internal plastic component responsible for regulating oil pressure. There have been numerous instances of this part fracturing in the field, leading to a sudden loss of oil pressure.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11721327
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING
Filed: Feb 2026

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that while driving approximately 45 MPH, the red oil light suddenly illuminated and the messages "Stop Carefully and Turn Off Engine", “Engine Oil Pressure Too Low", "Continued Driving will Result in Engine Damage". The vehicle was towed to the local mechanic, who discovered that the engine oil was black and thick.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11716801
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING
Filed: Nov 2025

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that while his wife was driving approximately 30-40 MPH, the message “Low Engine Oil” and to pull over to avoid engine destruction was displayed. The driver pulled over.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11700510
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: May 2025

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that while attempting to start the vehicle, the vehicle failed to start. There was no warning light illuminated.

NHTSA #: 11659512
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Nov 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. While the contact's wife was stopped and sitting in the drive-thru, the vehicle shut off. The vehicle was restarted; however, the vehicle failed to start as intended.

NHTSA #: 11626026
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Nov 2024

The contact owns 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that the vehicle was designed with the engine Auto Start/Stop system. The contact stated while at a complete stop and releasing the brake pedal, the engine failed to restart automatically.

NHTSA #: 11625163
highENGINE
Filed: Sep 2024

plastic oil pump housing/internals start to deteriorate and get metal debris into engine. 2019 ONLY.. bmw silently fixed this issue in 2020 models leaving anyone with the previous year stranded

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11612742
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Aug 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that the vehicle failed to start. The vehicle was towed to the dealer to be diagnosed.

NHTSA #: 11610024
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Aug 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated while the vehicle was parked, the vehicle failed to start. Additionally, there was a burning odor on the inside and outside of the vehicle while the vehicle was occupied.

NHTSA #: 11608743
highENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Aug 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that while at a stop light, the vehicle suddenly shut off and failed to restart. During the failure, the message "System Overheated" was displayed.

NHTSA #: 11607354
mediumENGINE
Filed: Jan 2026

Engine Starter overheating. Car won't start until engine cools down. Car would not let my shift into neutral in order to move to a safe location.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11708801
mediumENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: May 2025

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated while starting the vehicle, the vehicle hesitated to start immediately. The vehicle was taken to the dealer, who determined that the starter motor needed to be replaced.

NHTSA #: 11660393
mediumENGINE
Filed: Apr 2025

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated while driving 70 MPH and attempting to depress the accelerator pedal, the vehicle failed to accelerate as needed. No warning lights were illuminated.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11655860
mediumENGINE,FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM
Filed: Jan 2025

Our 2019 BMW X5 triggered a warning light requiring us to pull over immediately and tow the vehicle to the nearest dealer. It currently has 35,000 miles and the dealer informed us that the oil pump failed. After research and discussion with the dealer this has occurred with multiple 2019 X5's at that particular dealer as well as others.

NHTSA #: 11636219
mediumENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Dec 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact received notification of NHTSA Campaign Number: 24V576000(Electrical System, Engine and Engine Cooling). The vehicle was taken to the dealer where it was discovered that the recall software update remedy could not be completed due to the telemarket control module failing and needing to be replaced prior to the recall remedy.

NHTSA #: 11632409
mediumENGINE
Filed: Nov 2024

At 112,589 miles the oil level is never reaching full capacity, replaced oil levelling sensor, that did not resolve issue. Dealer stated oil pump starting to fail.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11626017
mediumENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING,ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
Filed: Nov 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact received notification of NHTSA Campaign Number: 24V576000 (Electrical System; Engine and Engine Cooling). The vehicle was taken to the dealer and the recall repair was performed.

NHTSA #: 11624743
mediumENGINE
Filed: Sep 2024

The contact owns a 2019 BMW X5. The contact stated that after starting the vehicle and driving at an undisclosed speed, the vehicle made abnormal sounds. No warning light was illuminated.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11613685
mediumENGINE
Filed: Jul 2023

Dear Sir This is regarding my 2019 BMW X5 VIN [XXX] , purchased on 5/28/2019 from BMW Orland Park IL. I encountered ‘Reduced engine power’ message on 5/8/2023. This vehicle was driven about 40000 miles at that time.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11533906
mediumENGINE
Filed: Mar 2021

Our vehicle is in for the 4th visit for a persistent oil leak. The first 2 visits resulted in a vehicle inspection and cleaning of engine area with no leak found, stating is was most likely left over oil from messy oil change. The 3rd visit resulted in replacing the rear main seal and problem was resolved per dealer.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11402810
mediumENGINE
Filed: Jan 2020

I parked my car in my garage, turned it off (the electronics powered down inside the car), and went inside. Approximately 4.5 hours later, my carbon monoxide detectors went off. I searched the home for the source and when I opened my garage door I discovered my vehicle engine had been running for about 4.5 hours in the closed the garage.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11306357
lowENGINE
Filed: Aug 2025

Known issue regarding failing oil pump in BMW B58 engines.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11679676
lowENGINE
Filed: Apr 2025

As my vehicle has an electronic oil level check system, I am unable to check my oil level. It gets to around 20% and then stops checking. As per my research, this is due to the oil pump on this particular model year that causes pressure fluctuations and results in this issue.

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11653194
lowENGINE
Filed: Feb 2025

Oil pressure warning

Parts you may need:

As an Amazon Associate, MyCarTSB earns from qualifying purchases.

NHTSA #: 11641034

Other 2019 Bmw X5 Issues